Machine Types and Brands

Serger vs Sewing Machine: Do You Need Both?

A sewing machine builds projects; a serger trims and finishes edges. What each does, what a serger can't do, and whether your sewing justifies owning both.

On this page
  1. Short answer
  2. What each machine does
  3. What a serger can’t do
  4. Do you need a serger?
  5. Finishing edges without a serger
  6. Serger vs coverstitch
  7. Costs beyond the purchase price
  8. If you do buy a serger: what to look for
  9. Our recommendation

Short answer

A sewing machine builds things: it sews seams, puts in zippers, makes buttonholes and topstitches. A serger (also called an overlocker) finishes things: it trims the seam allowance, sews the seam and wraps the raw edge in thread, all in one pass.

You need a sewing machine first. Whether you also need a serger depends on what you sew. It’s very useful for garments and knits, and much less important for quilting, mending and most crafts.

What each machine does

Sewing machine Serger
Main job Construction Seam finishing; seaming knits
Stitch Lockstitch (needle thread plus bobbin thread) Overlock stitch (typically 3–4 threads, using loopers; no bobbin)
Trims fabric No Yes, with a built-in knife
Stretch in the seam Limited; needs stretch or zigzag stitches for knits Naturally stretchy seams
Typical speed Roughly 700–1,100 stitches per minute on home machines Often 1,300 or more stitches per minute
Buttonholes, zippers, topstitching Yes No
Learning curve Gentler Steeper, mainly threading and tension

What a serger can’t do

A serger can’t replace a sewing machine. It can’t:

  • make buttonholes
  • insert most zippers
  • topstitch
  • sew a line of stitching in the middle of a piece of fabric
  • sew precise quilt piecing
  • sew darts in the usual way

Because the knife trims as you sew, mistakes are harder to undo: cut fabric stays cut.

Do you need a serger?

A serger is worth considering if you:

  • sew a lot of garments, especially from knit fabrics such as jersey, activewear fabric and sweatshirt fleece
  • want ready-to-wear-style seam finishes inside garments
  • sew loosely woven fabrics that fray badly
  • want fast rolled hems on scarves, napkins or chiffon
  • sew items to sell, where speed matters

You can probably skip it, at least for now, if you:

  • mostly quilt (quilt seams are enclosed and don’t need overlocking)
  • mainly mend or do alterations
  • sew bags, home décor or crafts
  • are just starting out and still building basic skills

Knit garments can be sewn entirely on a regular machine using a stretch stitch or narrow zigzag and a ballpoint needle. A serger makes the job faster and the result neater.

Finishing edges without a serger

A regular machine has several ways to stop fraying:

  • Zigzag along the raw edge, the simplest option
  • Overcast stitch with an overcast foot, which gets reasonably close to a serged look
  • French seams, which enclose raw edges on lightweight fabrics
  • Flat-felled seams, strong and neat on shirts and jeans
  • Bias binding (Hong Kong finish) on unlined jackets
  • Pinking shears, quick and simple for stable wovens

These take longer and don’t trim the edge, but they work well and many sewists use them for years before buying a serger.

Serger vs coverstitch

People often expect a serger to sew the twin-row stretch hem found on T-shirts. That’s a coverstitch, and most sergers don’t do it. Some combination machines do both but are more complex to convert between modes. You can imitate a coverstitch hem on a regular sewing machine with a twin needle, which gives two rows on top and a zigzag underneath.

Costs beyond the purchase price

  • Thread: sergers use three or four cones at once and consume thread quickly. Large cones are the practical choice.
  • Needles: many sergers specify ELx705 or a similar system rather than standard household needles. Check your manual, and see our guide on whether all needles fit all machines.
  • Knife blades wear and need occasional replacement.
  • Cleaning: sergers produce a lot of lint and need regular brushing out.
  • Space: a second machine needs its own spot to be convenient.

Basic sergers generally cost somewhat more than basic sewing machines, and the very cheapest sergers have a reputation for being harder to thread and balance. Many sewists feel it’s worth buying a step above the bottom of the range, or a serviced used model from a reputable brand.

If you do buy a serger: what to look for

  • 3/4-thread capability. This is the most common and versatile setup.
  • Differential feed, to prevent stretched or puckered seams on knits. Almost all current sergers have it.
  • Color-coded threading guides. Some higher-end models offer air threading, which many find makes threading much easier.
  • Rolled hem capability without complicated part changes.
  • Easy access to the loopers for threading and cleaning.
  • Local service and parts support.

Juki, Baby Lock, Brother, Janome, Bernina and others all make sergers. As with sewing machines, the specific model and local support matter more than the badge. See our guide to sewing machine types and brands for the wider brand landscape, or are Juki and Janome the same company? if you’re comparing those two.

Our recommendation

Buy a good sewing machine first and learn on it. If, after a while, you find yourself sewing garments regularly, especially knits, and spending a lot of time finishing seams, a serger is a worthwhile second machine. If you mainly quilt, mend or make crafts, a serger is optional, and the money may be better spent on a better primary machine or a walking foot.

The complete guide to machine types and brands

Sewing Machine Types and Brands: How to Choose
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →